How we age

Published on 20 October 2026 · Last updated on 20 October 2026 · Reading time about 14 minutes

More in Healthy ageing

Someone in their early fifties walks laughing along the North Sea beach with a person of the same age, a picture of healthy years of life.

In short

  • Three ageing researchers argue in GeroScience that the popular goal of “extending healthy years, not lifespan” is a misplaced cliché: in animal research, slowing ageing extended both the healthy years and the later years in poorer health.⁠1
  • In the Netherlands, life expectancy at birth in 2024 stood at 80.5 years for men and 83.2 years for women, while healthy life expectancy in 2025 came to 64.1 and 62.0 years.⁠2,3
  • The article is an argument, not an experiment: it reports no new research in humans or animals and tests no intervention.⁠1
  • The BioProfile lifestyle scan shows where your daily habits stand today. The scan is not a diagnosis and cannot predict how long you will live.

When you picture the years ahead

In this background article, you will read why three ageing researchers call the goal ‘not more years but good years’ a misplaced cliché, what their article in GeroScience argues and what it does not show. This matters because many people hope for good years rather than more years, and that hope quietly assumes a choice you may never actually have to make. Knowing what the research says helps you decide what you are aiming for in your own later years.

Portrait of Sonia Sanz Muñoz

Verified by Sonia Sanz Muñoz, PhD

PhD from the University of Wollongong

Checked on 6 November 2026

You walk up the stairs with two bags of shopping, and halfway up you notice it takes more breath than it used to. Nothing hurts and nothing is wrong. It is just a little slower. That evening, a news report says people are living longer than ever, and you are not sure whether that sounds like good news. You picture yourself much older, and the first thing you think of is not the number on the birthday cake. It is whether you will still carry your own shopping, cook your own meals and find your own words. A long life sounds good. A long life in which you depend on others for the basics sounds less good. So the wish many people arrive at is simple: not more years but good years.

That wish has also become a slogan in ageing research. Scientists call the healthy years healthspan and the whole of life lifespan, and you often read that the goal is to extend healthspan rather than lifespan. This background article is about three researchers who think that phrase sounds wise but does not hold up.

Living longer, but not all the extra years are healthy years

Two friends in their early fifties laugh as they pick out vegetables at a sunny market.

The official figures show how widely that concern is shared. Statistics Netherlands (CBS) reports that in 2024, life expectancy at birth was 80.5 years for men and 83.2 years for women.⁠2 For healthy life expectancy, the number of years a newborn is expected to spend in good health, CBS reports 64.1 years for men and 62.0 years for women in 2025.⁠3

The picture in Germany is similar. The German statistics office Destatis reports that average life expectancy at birth in 2025 came to 83.6 years for women and 79.1 years for men, the highest figure so far for both.⁠4

Put the two Dutch figures side by side and the gap between them is large: well over ten years for men, and larger still for women, who live longer on average but, in these figures, spend fewer years in good health. The figures come from neighbouring years, so this is not an exact count but a rough comparison. What it does show is that the later period of life in less than good health is not a rare experience. On average, that period takes up many years of a Dutch life.

Why ‘not more years but good years’ became the goal

The idea has a long history. In 1980, Fries pointed out in The New England Journal of Medicine that average life expectancy had risen from 47 to 73 years over the course of the twentieth century, while the maximum human lifespan had stayed the same.⁠5 If that upper limit does not shift, Fries reasoned, then keeping adults vigorous for longer compresses the period of decline into a short stretch just before the end. This became known as the compression of morbidity, and it fed a hopeful picture: live well for as long as possible, then decline quickly.⁠5 From there it was a small step to the slogan. If life has a ceiling, the useful work is to fill the years beneath it with health.

Recent data made the gap more urgent. A study of 183 member states of the World Health Organization, with data covering two decades, found that the distance between total lifespan and the years spent in good health had grown, to 9.6 years on average. In women, the gap was on average 2.4 years larger than in men. Of all the countries studied, the United States had the largest gap, 12.4 years, linked to a rise in long-term conditions that do not pass from person to person.⁠6

Laboratory research added a warning. In the tiny worm C. elegans, a favourite test animal in ageing research, all of the long-lived mutant strains studied spent a larger share of their lives in a frail state. The authors concluded that you should not assume lifespan and healthspan move together.⁠7

Taken together, this looked like a clear lesson: a longer life could simply mean a longer decline, so focus on health and leave length alone. What none of these findings settled is whether that aim makes sense as an aim at all. Can research add healthy years and leave the total untouched? And if a step did add years, some of them in poorer health, would you turn that step down?

Three researchers call the slogan a cliché

These questions are the subject of a new article by Gems, Iijima and de Magalhães. Gems and Iijima work at the Institute of Healthy Ageing and the Research Department of Genetics, Evolution and Environment at University College London. De Magalhães works at the University of Birmingham, in a lab that studies the genomics of ageing. Their article, titled ‘Against the “extend healthspan but not lifespan” cliché’, was published online in the journal GeroScience on 7 October 2026.⁠1

It is an opinion piece. The authors did not run a new experiment; they reason from what earlier research has shown. Their position is direct: the standard answer that the biology of ageing should extend healthspan rather than lifespan is, in their words, a misplaced cliché.⁠1 They are not alone in this. An editorial published earlier in 2026 in the journal Aging also argued that ageing research should aim for healthy life extension, extending life and the years in good health together, rather than playing the two off against each other as competing goals.⁠8

Why should this matter to you, on the stairs with your shopping? Because the wish for good years instead of more years quietly assumes a choice you may never really have to make. The article does not say that good years are unimportant. It says the two are linked: in practice, slowing ageing usually stretches both, and the real question is how you tip the balance towards health. That changes what a reasonable hope looks like. It is not a short life that stops at full strength. It is a long life in which the healthy part is as large as it can possibly be.

Gerospan: the part of life the slogan leaves out

Two people in their early fifties laugh as they cook a meal together with fresh vegetables in a bright kitchen.

The article turns on one idea, and it is worth looking at calmly. In this view, a life has two parts. The first is healthspan, the years in which you are in good health. The authors call the second gerospan: the later stage of life in poorer health.⁠1 Lifespan is the two together. Every long life has some of both, although the balance differs from one life to the next.

The slogan “extend healthspan, not lifespan” assumes you can grow the first part while the total stays the same, so the second part shrinks. The authors point to what animal research has actually found. In experiments with animal models, researchers were able to intervene in the ageing process, slow it down and extend lifespan. To varying degrees, that extended both parts: more healthy years, and more years in poorer health.⁠1 Slowing ageing did not just push the healthy part further out. It stretched the whole of life.

From there, the authors take two steps. The first is about what you aim for. For any comparable intervention in people, the desirable goal is to make the healthy years as many as possible and the later phase in poorer health as short as possible.⁠1 Few people would argue with that.

The second step is the one that undermines the slogan. Suppose an intervention did extend gerospan but also postponed death. Then that intervention would save lives, and the authors argue that in many circumstances it would be unethical to withhold it.⁠1 Their reason is simple: living with moderately reduced health is generally preferable to death. A goal like “extend healthspan but not lifespan” would ask researchers to reject something that people, on the whole, value.

That is why the authors conclude that ‘extending healthspan but not lifespan’ is not a coherent goal for research into ageing.⁠1 It sounds like a choice between two goals, but you cannot pursue one without affecting the other, and in their reading, refusing years of life that people value is not a defensible goal.

Two examples that make the idea concrete

The first example comes from the laboratory. In the worm C. elegans, long-lived mutant strains lived longer, but all the strains studied spent a larger share of their lives in a frail state.⁠7 In the language of the new article, their gerospan grew along with their lifespan. Through the lens of the old slogan, this looks like a failure: a longer life, more frailty. Through the lens of the article’s argument, it is a reminder of the real task: not to judge an intervention on length alone or on health alone, but to look at both parts and make the healthy part as large as possible.

The second example comes from everyday medical care. The authors point out that society already places real value on life-saving medical treatment that does not bring back full health.⁠1 When care keeps someone alive after a serious event, nobody turns that care down because life afterwards may come with less strength than before. The years gained are valued, even when they are not perfect years. The article asks why research into ageing should follow a different rule.

In an interview about the ethics of a long life, De Magalhães, one of the three authors, talked about the hope behind this kind of work:

If we can lift that limitation, people can live longer and, I would say, happier lives.⁠9

João Pedro de Magalhães, professor and ageing scientist; co-author of the article discussed, University of Birmingham

The words do not come from the article but from the interview. Read alongside the article, they make the same point from the hopeful side: longer and better belong together.

What the article does and does not show

What the article offers is a carefully built argument. It brings together what animal research has found about slowing ageing and draws from it a conclusion about what ageing research should aim for. Who was studied: no one. The article reports no new experiment, so there is no study population of people or animals, and no number of participants is reported.⁠1

That shapes what it cannot show. It does not show that any intervention exists today that slows ageing in humans. The evidence it rests on comes from animal models, and what happens in laboratory animals may not hold for humans. It does not say how much an intervention in humans would add to the healthy years or to the later phase, because no such intervention has ever been measured. It says nothing about your own later years or how you live them. And the central step is a judgement about values. The authors do not write ‘always’ but ‘in general’ and ‘in many circumstances’, and people may weigh their own later years differently. Finally, BioProfile has not read the full text of the article, only the abstract, so details that go beyond the abstract are not included here.

In short, and what you can do with this

Someone in their early fifties contentedly measures their waist with a tape measure at home in a sunny hallway.

In short: three ageing researchers argue in GeroScience that ‘extending healthspan, not lifespan’ is a misplaced cliché, because in animal research slowing ageing extended both the healthy years and the later years in poorer health.⁠1 In the Netherlands, CBS reports a life expectancy of 80.5 years for men and 83.2 years for women in 2024, and a healthy life expectancy of 64.1 and 62.0 years in 2025.⁠2,3 The article is an argument, not an experiment: it draws on animal research, tests nothing in people and rests on a judgement about values.⁠1

The first direction is to let go of the either-or. According to this article, good years and more years are not rivals. The useful question is not which one you want, but how large the healthy part of your own life can become.

The second direction is to look at the habits that shape your days now: how you move, sleep, eat and recover. None of them is a promise about your lifespan, but those habits are where you live your own healthy years. Daily eating is one example, and you can read how much energy an adult needs per day in how many calories per day.

The third direction is to separate your calendar age from how your body ages, a distinction explained in biological age versus calendar age.

How you can stretch your own healthy years is the open question, and research cannot yet answer it for any single person. What you can know is where you stand today. The lifestyle scan below gives you that starting point. The scan is not a diagnosis and does not predict how long you will live.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between healthy lifespan and lifespan?

Lifespan is your whole life. Healthspan is the part of it you spend in good health. The authors of the GeroScience article call the later stage of life in poorer health the gerospan, and lifespan is the two together.⁠1

Does living longer mean more years in poor health?

Not necessarily, but it can. In animal research, slowing ageing extended both the healthy years and the later stage in poorer health, to varying degrees.⁠1 In worms, long-lived strains spent a larger share of their lives in a frail state.⁠7 The goal the authors describe is to make the healthy part as large as possible.

How big is the gap between healthy years and total years?

Across 183 member states of the World Health Organization, the gap grew wider on average, to 9.6 years.⁠6 In the Netherlands, CBS reports a life expectancy of 80.5 years for men and 83.2 years for women in 2024, and a healthy life expectancy of 64.1 and 62.0 years in 2025.⁠2,3

Was anything tested in people in this research?

No. It is an opinion piece with no new experiment and no participants. It draws on earlier research in animal models and makes an argument about what ageing research should aim for.⁠1

Can the lifestyle scan tell me how long I will live?

No. The scan is not a diagnosis and makes no prediction about your lifespan. The scan shows where your lifestyle stands today, so you have a starting point.

Sources

Every source below was checked on the day this article was published. The numbering follows the text.

  1. Gems D, Iijima ER, de Magalhães JP. Against the “extend healthspan but not lifespan” cliché. GeroScience, 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s11357-026-02577-1
  2. CBS. Trends in sterfte en doodsoorzaken 2014-2024, 3. Aantal overledenen, levensverwachting en gestandaardiseerde sterfte. Statistische Trends, 2025. cbs.nl
  3. CBS. Monitor Brede Welvaart en de Sustainable Development Goals: Hier en nu, Gezondheid. 2026. cbs.nl
  4. Destatis. Lebenserwartung bei Geburt für Frauen und Männer im Jahr 2025 auf neue Höchstwerte gestiegen. Press release, 7 July 2026. destatis.de
  5. Fries JF. Aging, natural death, and the compression of morbidity. The New England Journal of Medicine, 1980;303(3):130-135. doi.org/10.1056/NEJM198007173030304
  6. Garmany A, Terzic A. Global Healthspan-Lifespan Gaps Among 183 World Health Organization Member States. JAMA Network Open, 2024;7(12):e2450241. doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.50241
  7. Bansal A, Zhu LJ, Yen K, Tissenbaum HA. Uncoupling lifespan and healthspan in Caenorhabditis elegans longevity mutants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2015;112(3):E277-E286. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1412192112
  8. Barzilai DA. Healthy life extension: Geroscience’s north star. Aging (Albany NY), 2026;18(1):100-101. doi.org/10.18632/aging.206359
  9. João Pedro de Magalhães, professor, University of Birmingham. João Pedro de Magalhães on the Ethics of Longevity (interview by Arkadi Mazin). Lifespan.io, 2026. lifespan.io

Quotations from English have been translated by BioProfile.

See where your healthy years of life begin

The lifestyle scan looks at how you live today and shows where you stand, as a starting point. The scan is not a diagnosis and does not predict how long you will live.

Free, about 3 minutes. An analysis of your answers, never a diagnosis.